Skating by in a given college course should, by definition, award a student a C at the end of the semester, but according to a recent study at the University of California, Irvine, some students now expect higher grades for doing the bare minimum. The study, which appeared in the Journal of Youth and Adolescence in November, found that 40.7 percent of students surveyed said they deserved Bs for completing most of the course readings, and about a third said they should earn a B for attending most of the classes. But, according to the grade policy at the University of Minnesota, if a student simply âĂ„Ăşmeets the course requirements,âĂ„Ăą he or she should get a C. To get a B, students must show âĂ„Ăşachievement significantly above the level necessary to meet course requirements.âĂ„Ăą Allison Goetsch , a University first-year biomedical engineering student, said she expects to receive good grades. âĂ„ĂşEverything thatâĂ„Ă´s always come easy, like calc. and any science class, I pretty much just assume IâĂ„Ă´ll get an A in, and if I donâĂ„Ă´t, IâĂ„Ă´m really surprised,âĂ„Ăą Goetsch said. Corporate environmental management senior Sondra Larson, however, agrees with University policy. âĂ„ĂşIf you do the work, you get a C,âĂ„Ăą she said. âĂ„ĂşI think that itâĂ„Ă´s not that difficult to get a B, to put in the extra effort. If you want it, you should work for it.âĂ„Ăą In the study, nearly two-thirds of students surveyed said they felt that if they explained to a professor that they were trying hard, the professor should take that into consideration to determine their grade. Brad Dickerman said he thinks effort should count. âĂ„ĂşI feel like, if I put the work in to actually understand the material, I feel like I deserve better than a C,âĂ„Ăą the junior chemical engineering student said. The study attributed studentsâĂ„Ă´ sense of academic entitlement to various factors, including parental expectations, competition among students, and personality variables like narcissism and self-esteem. Timothy Brennan, a professor in the UniversityâĂ„Ă´s cultural studies and comparative literature department, offered another theory. âĂ„ĂşItâĂ„Ă´s much more complicated than just students in this generation feeling a certain kind of privilege,âĂ„Ăą Brennan said, adding that he thinks there is a structural problem within universities. Students, he said, tend to give higher evaluations to professors who grade more easily, and because there is a direct link between teaching evaluation scores and salary, grade inflation has become the norm for many professors. âĂ„ĂşOn those grounds, the students expect to be graded more highly than they probably deserve,âĂ„Ăą Brennan said. âĂ„ĂşAs a practice, I admit that I grade people higher than I think they deserve.âĂ„Ăą The study acknowledged grade inflation as a possible factor to sense of entitlement, citing a 1999 study that indicated an increase over time in average grades at research universities. âĂ„ĂşIf students learn that they can get a high grade with minimal effort, we should not be surprised if they develop entitled attitudes,âĂ„Ăą the study stated. Douglas Lewis , a philosophy professor at the University, said he is aware of the tendency toward grade inflation, but he tries to adhere to the UniversityâĂ„Ă´s definition that a C is the standard. âĂ„Ăş[Students] complain,âĂ„Ăą Lewis said. âĂ„ĂşItâĂ„Ă´s pretty well-entrenched that theyâĂ„Ă´re supposed to get high grades.âĂ„Ăą Brennan said thereâĂ„Ă´s simply less work involved for faculty members if they give students the grades they want. âĂ„ĂşIf you give a high grade, they donâĂ„Ă´t complain,âĂ„Ăą he said. Lewis said instead of raising a studentâĂ„Ă´s grade after a complaint is received, he explains how their work can be improved. âĂ„ĂşIâĂ„Ă´m fighting a battle, a losing battle, but IâĂ„Ă´m determined to fight it anyway,âĂ„Ăą he said. âĂ„ĂşIf we give them Bs when their work is only C-level, weâĂ„Ă´re misleading them, and weâĂ„Ă´re failing in our educational responsibilities.âĂ„Ăą
Students expect high grades
Professors admit to pressure from students for higher grades.
Published March 12, 2009
1
More to Discover