Healthcare Workers for Palestine Twin Cities hosted a press conference outside the Minnesota State Capitol in St. Paul on Oct. 25 to discuss the censorship of health care workers expressing their thoughts about the war in Palestine.
Around 50 people attended the press conference, which lasted about two hours and advocated for health care workers’ ability to speak in support of Palestinians and Palestinian Americans.
The attending speakers came from Students for Justice in Palestine, American Muslims for Palestine, Families Against Military Madness, White Coats for Black Lives and Jewish Voice for Peace.
Some of the attendees, many of them wearing scrubs, donned masks with the words “censored” and “silenced” over their mouths.
Dr. Asfia Qaadir presented a live webinar on Zoom for PrairieCare in July about supporting patients from diverse backgrounds, including Palestinians. PrairieCare sent out an apology regarding the content of the Zoom and announced it would not be posted for viewing after the fact, Alycia Garubanda, a speech pathologist at Abbott Northwestern Hospital who attended Qaadir’s live webinar, said.
Many health care workers who supported Palestine felt they were unable to fully support their patients after PrairieCare’s reaction to the webinar, Garubanda said.
The rally consisted of speeches, chants and music. The speeches contained personal thoughts and experiences as well as the stories of Palestinian health care workers killed in the war.
Many of the speeches expressed concern regarding the censorship of health care workers when speaking about Palestine at work.
Qaadir, a child and adolescent psychiatrist at PrairieCare who presented a training webinar on supporting BIPOC and Palestinian patients, said censoring health care workers worried her, largely due to the implications it puts on caring for patients.
“Right now across the U.S., there is a widespread practice of banning Palestinian health education inside of hospitals, and people don’t realize that that’s happening,” Qaadir said. “That’s very problematic because it makes it impossible for us as health care workers to render trauma-informed care, to do best practices with all our patients.”
Garubanda said it is apparent to her the health care system does not want its providers to talk about Palestine. She said the health care system is hypocritical in how it prioritizes diversity, equity and inclusion.
“Every health care institution’s statements and values around DEI and racial equity are, frankly, garbage,” Garubanda said. “We can’t believe what you say because we see what you do. Your silencing us is directly harming our patients in this community.”
It is a disservice to the patients of providers to not educate them about these issues, Garubanda said.
“We cannot effectively treat any of our patients if we don’t understand the context that brings them to us,” Garubanda said. “And understanding historical, generational trauma and effects of all of this is vital for us to show up for our patients. If we pretend like our patients just arrive to us without any background before they arrive, we are not treating them effectively.”
Maryam Waz, a Palestinian-American nurse and University Medical School student who shortened her last name to protect her family still in Palestine, said ignoring the war goes against what it means to be a health care provider.
Waz said she was frustrated by her situation as a medical student.
“We have health care workers dying by the thousands, and my people dying, and I’m just supposed to go to class and pretend it’s okay and learn about these theories that they themselves don’t apply,” Waz said. “You learn about all these theories of socialist advocacy, yet there’s not one email, one message, just nothing.”
Qaadir said she hopes the actions taken by PrairieCare to not make her webinar available to the public can be an opportunity for reflection within the health care community.
“The hope is that this becomes an opportunity for PrairieCare to have a dialogue with the community, listen to the concerns, and then, hopefully, rise to that moment and really show up in the community,” Qaadir said. “That’s historically what PrairieCare has done.”
Correction: A previous version of this article said that there was a speaker from Minnesota Christians for a Free Palestine. Minnesota Christians for a Free Palestine did endorse the event but weren’t represented among the speakers. Jewish Voice for Peace did speak at the event.
KG
Nov 6, 2024 at 8:59 am
BMO, if you’re genuinely concerned about “humanity,” I hope you would address the 1,200 innocent people—primarily women and children—killed by Hamas on October 7, 2023, and the 250 taken hostage into Gaza. On that day, Hamas militants invaded Israeli villages, committing genocide and ethnic cleansing. They inflicted systematic atrocities, including documented cases of mass rape, burning families in their homes, and executing civilians in a calculated, brutal sweep. Many of these crimes were proudly captured on video by the attackers themselves, leaving no doubt about the intentionality and scale of their actions.
Beyond the murders, over 100 hostages still remain captive in Gaza, including civilians from diverse backgrounds (including Muslims). Thousands of Israelis are displaced due to relentless rocket attacks targeting civilian areas. Recently, an Israeli girl released by Hamas tragically took her life, unable to endure the trauma. It’s clear that genuine humanity involves condemning these atrocities.
PrarieCare is wise to focus on healthcare and stay away from false and divisive narratives.
BMO
Nov 5, 2024 at 12:16 pm
God bless these beautiful people! You are the righteous!!! Dont listen to the commentor KG they are dead inside and have no connection to their humanity.
KG
Nov 4, 2024 at 12:15 pm
I always thought medical service personnel prioritized selflessness, dedicating their focus and energy to patient care. This article, however, has highlighted that some extremist, Hamas-supporting medical personnel are more invested in their political agenda than in their commitment to healthcare. By referencing “Palestinian education inside hospitals,” these demonstrators are aiming to inject their anti-Israel stance and narrative into PrairieCare facilities—a message underscored when they cite “stories of Palestinian healthcare workers killed in the war.” But these claims stem from a distorted narrative meant to undermine Israel’s legitimacy, which can increase patient anxiety, especially among those who don’t share these views.
It’s essential to recognize this narrative’s inaccuracy. Hamas’s October 7 terrorist invasion of Israel led to unspeakable violence, targeting civilians and committing acts of genocide against Israeli villages. Israel’s conflict is with Hamas, a terrorist organization, not the Palestinian people. Hamas’s tactics of using civilians as human shields make them responsible for the this conflict’s vast toll.
Furthermore, evidence exists of Hamas’s connections to Gaza’s medical personnel. For instance, a Gaza doctor was found harboring an Israeli hostage, and Hamas is known to use ambulances to transport operatives and arms. This dangerous blurring of roles shows how their propaganda could infiltrate healthcare settings. PrairieCare deserves commendation for maintaining a neutral, safe environment, free from external political agendas, ensuring all patients receive care with professionalism and without bias.